It is definitely partly Polachek because, MY GOD, how obtuse do you need to be, how ignorant to think that the experience of another woman—especially one of a different race—is actually all about you? I am always the only Black woman in my yoga classes. But instead, the editors at xoJane recognized that an article that essentially trolls women of color would be a much better page view generator and so abandoned their responsibility to the story at hand. You are commenting using your Google account. But, I read the entire essay, and you should too. What would you do if that happened to you?
My practice is about me. The aim of getting people talking can overshadow the task of helping the writers become better writers. The marketing of yoga in contemporary America as just another fitness routine and the preponderance of skinny white women just like Polachek in yoga magazines and in yoga videos is actually very troubling and worth a discussion. But so anyway, the real issue is that xoJane even ran this piece as written at all. What is most problematic to me about Ms. You are commenting using your Twitter account. Is this because Black women struggle with yoga?
I’m the only Black woman in my yoga class but… – ZenG Yoga
I am always the only Black woman in my yoga classes. Which, actually, a very good discussion about that issue can be found here, on the excellent site Decolonizing Yoga. It is definitely partly Polachek because, MY GOD, how obtuse do you need to be, how ignorant to think that the experience of another woman—especially one of a different race—is actually all about you? Home News Community Help! But, let me keep it all the way real here.
Because I was directly in front of her, I had no choice but to look straight at her every time my head was upside down roughly once a minute. Suddenly, in a yoga class, the heavy, black body threatens the safe, comfortable zone xpjane belongs to this white woman.
You have entered an incorrect email address! Within the first few minutes of gentle warm-up stretches, I saw the fear in her eyes snowball, turning into panic and then despair. xojand
The recent xojame fallout over the essay published on xojane. Even sampling just one paragraph from the essay should give you an idea of how quickly everything goes to hell: Why do so many women of color continue to practice yoga despite narratives like the one Ms. Would you spend the whole class preoccupied with your own sophomoric thoughts and then go home and cry because esssay was just too stressful for you to practice yoga with a black woman?
She stayed there, staring, for the rest of the class. What is most problematic to me about Ms. Or, you know, maybe this young black woman is not a bitch, but she sure did make Polachek incredibly uncomfortable.
For that reason, I am pursuing this training because one, I want to deepen my own practice and two, I want to create yoga spaces where women and men of color know that they are welcomed and expected.
Even sampling just one paragraph from the essay should give you an idea of how quickly everything goes to hell:. Please enter your comment! When I practice yoga, I carve out my own space and focus on my flow.
xoJane’s Embarrassing Yoga Essay and the Problem With “Honest” Writing
They see themselves get published, and think: Her dissolution into a crying fit strikes me as an out-of-the-ordinary reaction, and it does make her seem like a narcissist who yogs mostly upset by inequality in yoga because of the way it shakes her out of her own self-satisfaction. Smackdowns have their uses. When Gawker found this piece yesterday and made pretty good fun of itthere was a certain catharsis in seeing everyone turn on the piece so swiftly.
Email required Address never made public. Making a Safe Space for Music, and a Movement. She went home and cried because the presence of this one Black woman presented her with a moral crisis and interrupted her flow. Leave a Reply Cancel reply Enter your comment here That will make it easier to point and laugh them out of existence.
This is all about you now?!
Surely this woman was noticing all esway these things and judging me for them, stereotyping me, resenting me—or so I imagined. And then, in a moment of profound but apparently unintentional irony, she closes on the following question:. There is certainly some value in having bigots be openly bigoted, in the sense that then the rest of us know just where they are. There is perhaps a good conversation to be had about that.
And, health and wellness do not belong to you. The problem with these pieces being sort of inherently ridiculous is that the discussions they provoke are equally shallow.